How to Tell if the Directories & Other Online Listings are Working in Less than 10 Seconds

Updated on: 19-11-2021 by WEB-ROI

I often get calls from clients that sound something like this: “Should I renew – yellow pages, gold book, canpages, xyz advertising, this directory, that industry listing etc?”

To answer this question, referrals (referring traffic listed under traffic sources in your Google Analytics), is the first place I look. This is where all of the traffic to your website is recorded (if it didn’t come from a major search engine).

The chart below is for the month of May for one of our clients:


 Here’s how we interpret it in less than 10 seconds:

1. The top referral source was a forum on

This is a great example of “web 2.0”, social media etc at its best! Usually what happens in these cases is someone posts a question on the form asking where to get a good deal on a certain product/service and others answer.

This is something beyond the client’s control- the key is to make sure you have brand monitoring in place so you know what is being said about you (and you can sign up and respond (in a pleasant way!!)  if something is stated that’s not accurate).

This is a relatively popular forum in our area, I’ve seen it drive a lot of business to soil companies, a k-cup supplier, a door & window company.

2. is a similar type of forum

This one is very exclusive to a portion of Milton, the town of 100,000 I live in and one of the towns that this client services.

3. The last referral source is

Quite simply this traditional mode of advertising, which was so successful for so many years (everyone ‘let their fingers do the walking’) has been the biggest complaint from business owners over the last couple of years.  The numbers speak for themselves.

sources2In this case there were 32 visits in a month (which is more than we usually see). The
visitors are very engaged, and as per the chart below we see that 6.25% of the 32 visits filled in a form on the site (getting to the thank you page and accomplishing a goal, as per the first part of our series).  So, only 2 leads in their busiest month of the year from the Yellow Pages.

The client then needs to divide what they spent on the listing by the number of leads, and then determine if that’s a reasonable amount of cash to put out per lead- this is how you determine if your directories and listings are working.

Most business owners who call us wondering whether or not to review an ad source see numbers somewhere around 30-80 visits for the year from directories like Goldbook, Canpages, and Yellow Pages sending around 130 visits for the year.

With this data at least you can do the math and make some good business decisions!

Next Post Will Show You How to Evaluate & Compare the Traffic You Receive From Search Engines

Stay tuned for my next post, or for more practical online marketing advice for small business owners, download our newest ebook & learn how to avoid committing some of the most common website and marketing errors.

83114351 1f52 4e5e b885 cdcc3294de3c

Sign me up for tips, tricks, and updates.

Do not send automated emails
For HubSpot
Agency Owner
ready to see results?

The prize is a high-traffic website that generates quality leads.

With a high-traffic website designed to convert quality leads into paying customers you can shift your focus to other areas of your business (or reclaim some much-needed personal time).

Stop driving in circles. Choose digital marketing services guaranteed to get you to the finish line. With an award-winning website design company like WEB ROI at your side, it won't take long to achieve your goals.

Get Your FREE Guide Now
WEB ROI logo
high traffic website in Canada